Back to the canvas
Process
The four-seat loop
Plan, execute, review and gate, with the reviewers kept independent of the executor.
What it shows
The loop this site is built with. Work starts from a backlog item and a spec. One seat plans and writes the acceptance criteria, another executes, and two reviews follow: one of the code, one against the acceptance criteria.
The reviews only report. The decision belongs to the last seat, a deterministic gate that is a script and never a model. The pre-commit hook and CI run the same gate.
Key decisions
- The executor and the code reviewer come from different model families, so a review is not a model agreeing with itself.
- Reviews report; they do not edit and they do not decide.
- The gate is deterministic: the same input gives the same answer, in the hook and in CI.